Collar vs. Harness: How to Choose the Right Accessory for Your Dog
- dogpediaitaly
- Sep 15
- 3 min read
When walking your dog, choosing between a collar and harness isn't just a matter of appearance, but a crucial step to ensuring your dog's safety and comfort, as well as providing a pleasant walking experience for both of you. The decision depends on several factors, including your four-legged friend's breed , body type , personality , and training level .
Collar: Advantages and disadvantages
The collar is the most traditional and widely used accessory. It is used to attach identification tags and is usually useful for walks.
Advantages:
Ease of use: Putting on and taking off is quick.
Direct Control: Allows immediate control of the dog's head, useful for basic training.
Lightweight: It is not bulky and does not restrict the dog's movements.
Disadvantages:
Health risks: Excessive pulling can put pressure on the trachea, spine, and nerves in the neck, causing long-term damage. This is especially dangerous for dogs with breathing problems or brachycephalic breeds like pugs or bulldogs .
Escape potential: If the dog backs away, he can easily free himself from the collar.
Force distribution: The pressure is concentrated on a very small area, the neck, which is particularly sensitive.
Tableware: Advantages and disadvantages
The harness distributes pressure over a larger area of the dog's body—namely the chest and shoulders—making pulling less damaging. It is often recommended by veterinarians and trainers.
Advantages:
Safety: Reduces the risk of neck and trachea injuries, especially in the event of sudden impacts.
Better control: It provides more effective control and makes it harder for the dog to pull or slip. There are anti-pull models where the leash ring rests on the chest, preventing the dog from pulling.
Ideal for vulnerable breeds: Essential for dogs with sensitive tracheas, such as Yorkshire Terriers or Chihuahuas , and for brachycephalic breeds (e.g. French Bulldogs ).
Disadvantages:
Risk of chafing: If it doesn't fit properly, it can cause chafing under the armpits.
Bulky: Can be more complicated to carry, although many modern models are very practical.
Restricted movement: Some designs can restrict the natural movement of your dog's shoulders if they are not constructed properly.
Collar or harness: The choice depends on the breed and personality of your dog
The choice between a collar and harness should be made individually. Here are some guidelines for different dog types.
1. Dogs that pull a lot (e.g. Husky, Labrador, German Shepherd)
For strong, energetic dogs prone to pulling, an anti-pull harness is the safest and most effective solution. It distributes the force and helps your dog walk beside you without pulling, thus protecting his health.
2. Small and sensitive breeds (e.g. Pug, Maltese, Greyhound)
Breeds with sensitive tracheas or thin, fragile necks should use a harness to avoid the risk of injury. A harness is also preferable for greyhounds , whose neck structure is unique, to prevent slippage and injury.
3. Older dogs or dogs with health problems
If your dog has neck, back, or joint problems, a harness is the best choice. It reduces pressure on these sensitive areas and provides better support while walking.
4. Well-behaved, non-pulling dogs
For dogs who walk perfectly on a leash, a collar can be a good and comfortable choice. Make sure it's not too tight and doesn't cause discomfort.
5. Puppies
For puppies, a harness is often the best choice. It helps them get used to the leash without putting pressure on their still-growing and very sensitive necks.
Diploma
There's no one-size-fits-all answer to the question "collar or harness." The best solution is always the one that maximizes your dog's comfort and safety and is tailored to their specific needs.
In many cases, a harness proves to be the safest and most beneficial choice in the long run. If in doubt, consult your veterinarian or a professional trainer for personalized advice and to ensure you're making the right choice for your loyal friend's well-being.
Comments